Inner Circle Newsletter February 2025

The Who What When Where Why

Open Research Institute is a non-profit dedicated to open source digital radio work. We do both technical and regulatory work. Our designs are intended for both space and terrestrial deployment. We’re all volunteer. 

You can get involved by visiting https://openresearch.institute/getting-started 

Membership is free. All work is published to the general public at no cost. Our work can be reviewed and designs downloaded at https://github.com/OpenResearchInstitute

We equally value ethical behavior and over-the-air demonstrations of innovative and relevant open source solutions. We offer remotely accessible lab benches for microwave band radio hardware and software development. We host meetups and events at least once a week. Members come from around the world. 

ORI’s AmbaSat Payload Moves Forward

AmbaSat writes: “For any space satellite company, the journey to orbit is filled with challenges. Designing and testing hardware, developing software, and securing a launch provider are all major hurdles. However, one of the most rigorous and complex aspects of this journey is meeting the regulatory requirements for an Orbital Operations Licence. 

After an immense amount of work, we’re thrilled to announce that we have officially submitted our Orbital Operations Licence application to the UK Civil Aviation Authority (CAA). 

This marks a significant milestone for AmbaSat. It’s been a long road to get here, filled with dedication, innovation, and perseverance. Of course, submission is just the beginning—there’s still plenty of work ahead. But this moment brings us one step closer to orbit, and we couldn’t be more excited. 

Now, we enter the final phase of preparation—think of it as reaching the last level of a game, where the ultimate challenge awaits: launching into space.”

ORI is an early supporter of AmbaSat and has used the board in several ways. One of the modifications to the board can be found at https://github.com/ambasat/AmbaSat-1/pull/10

We made a number of these modified boards and the performance was improved. 

We will send our original AmbaSat board in for integration into the payload and a UK launch after the license application process successfully concludes. 

We have leveraged AmbaSat to great success as an educational platform and look forward to it reaching space. 

Earth-Venus-Earth: Bouncing Signals Off Our Planetary Neighbor

What is the Earth-Venus-Earth Project?

The Earth-Venus-Earth (EVE) project is an ambitious radio communications experiment from the citizen science and amateur radio communities working to bounce radio signals off the planet Venus and receive them back on Earth. 

Why Venus?

Venus is our closest planetary neighbor and presents a fascinating target for radio experiments. When Venus is at its closest approach to Earth, we have the best chance of using it as a reflective surface for certain radio frequencies. By bouncing signals off Venus, we can:

1. Push the boundaries of amateur radio capabilities

2. Gather more data about Venus’s atmospheric and surface communications reflectivity properties

3. Develop techniques that could be useful for future deep space amateur communications

4. Achieve something extraordinary with open-source technology and collaborative effort

Our Contribution: Can the Connection be Made?

One of the most crucial aspects of any radio communications project is understanding whether a signal can successfully travel from point A to point B (and in our case, back to point A again). This is where our work on the EVE link budget comes in.

What’s a Link Budget?

A link budget is essentially an accounting of all the factors that strengthen or weaken a radio signal as it travels. Imagine tracking a water droplet’s journey through a series of pipes, pumps, and filters – you need to know where water is added or lost to understand if enough will reach the destination. Or imagine tracking your income and expenses over the course of a month. 

Similarly, with radio signals, we need to account for:

– How much power we can transmit from Earth

– How much signal is lost traveling through space

– How much signal scatters when it hits Venus

– How much returns toward Earth

– How sensitive our receiving equipment must be to detect the returning signal

Our Achievements

Volunteers at Open Research Institute have developed a comprehensive link budget model for the EVE project that demonstrates feasibility, required specifications, timing windows, and open collaboration. 

1. Feasibility: We’ve shown that with access to some of the largest amateur dishes, such as at DSES, Dwingeloo, Stockert, and potentially other sites, that amateur radio equipment and techniques can potentially bounce signals off Venus. Probably the most significant contribution is showing mathematically how difficult EVE is and how nearly all weak signal modes that currently exist in amateur radio will not close the link. 

2. Required Specifications: We’ve determined the minimum requirements for transmitters, antennas, and receivers needed to make this connection. We’ve contributed several new sections and quantified techniques for this attempt. 

3. Timing Windows: We’ve mapped the optimal time periods when Venus is positioned correctly relative to Earth for successful signal reflection, and identified challenging characteristics in the radio environment. 

4. Open Collaboration: All our calculations, models, and results are openly shared, allowing amateur radio operators worldwide to participate in, critique, correct, or reproduce our work.

What Makes This Special

What sets our work apart is that we’re approaching this as an open research initiative. The link budget work we’ve completed serves as a roadmap for anyone interested in participating in or learning more about Earth-Venus-Earth communications. 

Next Steps

With our link budget analysis nearing completion we’re now considering putting together an Earth-Mars-Earth link budget. We are also studying the possibility of whether distributed receivers can be used for Earth-Moon-Earth to achieve anything of note. 

Join the Exploration

If you’re interested in radio, space, or innovative open research, we welcome your participation. The beauty of open research is that everyone brings unique perspectives and skills that strengthen the entire project. Visit the Open Research Institute website at https://openresearch.institute/getting-started to learn how you can be part of this exciting journey to bounce signals off our planetary neighbor.

This project represents the collaborative effort of many contributors at Open Research Institute, advancing our understanding of both radio technology and our solar system through open development and shared discovery.

Current link budget can be found at https://github.com/OpenResearchInstitute/documents/blob/master/Engineering/Link_Budget/Link_Budget_Modeling.ipynb

Successful Collaboration with IEEE Leads to Practical AI/ML Design Work at ORI

Michelle Thompson W5NYV and Matthew Wishek NB0X organized a meetup about the Role of Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning (AI/ML) in Register Transfer Logic Design (RTL) Generation. The Open Source Digital Radio IEEE Local Group and the San Diego Chapter of the IEEE Information Theory Society co-hosted the online event. The meeting was held on 28 January 2025 and a recording can be found at https://youtu.be/8xDxeUxWTCc 

AI/ML in RTL Design Generation

In the meeting, Michelle and Matthew presented about the potential of artificial intelligence and machine learning in Electronic Design Automation (EDA) frameworks. The central question of the meetup was to try and answer where the AI/ML can help the RTL design generation process. They identified core concepts from an open-source perspective and discussed the importance of reducing schedule, technical, and cost risks in the design process. Matthew highlighted the iterative nature of the design process and the need for early identification of design deficiencies and incorrect assumptions. He also suggested the use of AI agents to guide the high-level synthesis process, assist in design space exploration, and improve the performance of place and route. 

Michelle discussed the potential of open-source EDA and shared specific recommendations from a European white paper ” Roadmap and Recommendations for Open Source EDA in Europe”, which can be found at https://fossi-foundation.org/resources/eu-roadmap

Michelle highlighted the challenges of limited access to EDA software and the semiconductor workforce shortage in the US. These are problems also shared by the tech industry in Europe. She mentioned the positive impact of open-source initiatives like the RISC-V processor and the Google Skywater Process Design Kit (PDK). The technical recommendations from the paper included focusing more on analog and mixed-signal designs, interoperability and verification, and system-on-chip integration. She also emphasized the importance of proper licensing, funding, sustainability, and industry training for both open-source and AI/ML projects. Another recommendation from Free and Open Source Silicon (FOSSi) Foundation was for more conferences, workshops, and events to better distribute  the vast amount of innovative and exciting information and developments in this field. 

Michelle discussed the use of large language models and automated writing of HDL for design IP. She shared her experience with ORI’s Remote Labs Matlab HDL Coder toolbox, which can produce high-quality, human-readable HDL code but requires a lengthy process and is not suitable for complex monolithic designs. She also mentioned the use of AI and ML in deep learning hardware models and their potential to inform the design process. Michelle explained a survey of experts in the field, which showed a bias towards proprietary tools being perceived as high-quality, and lesser expectations concerning quality from both Open Source and AI/ML tools. Matthew then introduced a set of relevant papers he had found in his literature search, focusing on areas such as RTL generation, hardware verification, testbench generation, and formal verification. His call for action was to try to put some of the potential of the work published in these papers to inform and improve the design process into actual Open Source practice. 

Matthew talked about about the role of of AI/ML in analog design, signal processing, and network planning. He suggested that AI tools can help with analog design, potentially enabling non-specialists to experiment and learn. He discussed the use of AI/ML in detecting convolutional codes, channel estimation, and radio map generation for network planning. There is significant overlap with information theory in these applications, particularly in tracking entropy levels in codes and signals. Michelle mentioned that the Information Theory and Applications Workshop 9-14 February 2025 would probably have a lot of AI/ML content. She then described successful technology demonstrations by DARPA in 2019 showing improved spectrum efficiency using AI/ML models. This proof of concept from DARPA sparked a great deal of interest from academia, industry, and regulators. 

Daniel, Michelle, and Matthew discussed the pros and cons of using proprietary versus open-source Electronic Design Automation (EDA) tools. Michelle described the challenges of open-source projects, such as the lack of funding, limited market size, and difficulty in maintaining quality. Matthew shared his experience with open-source simulators, noting their limitations in terms of feature set parity and language coverage. Daniel suggested that open-source solutions might take longer to develop but could benefit from advancements in AI tools. Michelle and Matthew agreed that the EDA market is small, which contributes to the high cost of proprietary tools. The consensus from the participants was that while there are good open-source projects addressing AI/ML in RTL design generation, many of them may not yet be ready for complex designs.

It was resolved to pick one or more of the many tools and projects mentioned in the presentation, and give it a try. Reports about the first-hand experiences would then be shared in future IEEE meeting collaborations, to put the recommendations from FOSSi and the rubrics from Matthew into better context.

AI RTTY and DeepReceiver

After the EDA meeting, the search for applications of interest to the ORI community sharpened into further focus. 

Matthew found a survey paper “Deep Learning in Wireless Communication Receiver: A Study” by Doha and Abdelhadi. One of the references was a paper about a project called DeepReceiver, titled “DeepReceiver: A Deep Learning-Based Intelligent Receiver for Wireless Communication in the Physical Layer”. These papers helped us figure out the next step for the Artificial Intelligent Radio Teletype (RTTY) receiver project.

Up until this point, our machine learning model identified one stand-alone individually transmitted RTTY letter at a time. The DeepReceiver paper provided the inspiration and the education to update the model to something much more realistic. 

In order to be useful, an AI RTTY receiver has to be able to translate whole “sentences” of RTTY “speech”, and not just individual characters given one at a time. 

We are happy to announce that our article about this work, “An Artificially Intelligent RTTY Receiver”, has been accepted for publication in ARRL QEX magazine.

ORI Celebrated National Engineers Week 16-23 February 2025


We were delighted to be part of the San Diego County Engineering Council’s annual awards banquet and celebration of Engineer’s Week. 

We were able to present our work and give away some keepsake items at the San Diego Section IEEE booth. Thank you to IEEE for sharing their space with us so that we can spread the word about open source digital radio.

Questions and comments we fielded at the event included:

“How does it work when you give away your solutions? Isn’t that stealing?”

“How do you make money doing this?”

“Does anyone use open source designs?” 

“I’ve heard of open source software, but I’ve never heard of open source hardware.”

It was a great opportunity to educate people about open source software, firmware, and hardware, the value it brings to technology in general and the value it brings to digital communications (especially including the Internet!).

Inner Circle Newsletter February 2023

Greetings all! Welcome to the February 2023 issue of the Inner Circle Newsletter from Open Research Institute.

Join the Inner Circle

Sign up for this newsletter at http://eepurl.com/h_hYzL

Thank you so much for your time, attention, and support. We appreciate you, we welcome your feedback, and we are dedicated to serving the community to the best of our abilities. You can get in touch with the ORI board of directors directly at hello@operesearch.institute.

A Puzzle Just For Fun

Here’s a puzzle. Chicken Nuggets have been on the menu at the international fast food chain McDonald’s since 1983.

If Chicken McNuggets are sold in packs of 6, 9, or 20, then what is the largest number of nuggets that cannot be ordered?

Answer is at the end of this newsletter!

Projects

Our volunteer teams have been busy and successful, and our project lineup has grown.

Regulatory Efforts: ORI works hard to promote and defend open source digital radio work. We do all we can to help move technology from proprietary and controlled to open and free. Our work on ITAR, EAR, Debris Mitigation, and AI/ML are where we have spent most of our time over the past two years. We were a member of the Technological Advisory Committee for the US Federal Communications Commission in 2022, and co-chaired the Safe Uses of AI/ML Subworking Group. We have received consistently positive reviews for all of our work, and there has been increasing use of the results.

Ribbit: this open source communications protocol uses the highest performance error correction and modern techniques available to turn any analog radio into an efficient and useful digital text terminal. No wires, no extra equipment. The only thing you’ll need to use it is the free open source Android or IoS app on your phone. Learn how to use this communications system and get involved in building a truly innovative open source tactical radio service by visiting https://ribbitradio.org

Join Ribbit mailing lists at: https://www.openresearch.institute/mailing-lists/

Amateur Satellite: ORI has the world’s first and only open source HEO/GEO communications satellite program, called Haifuraiya. We will demonstrate all working parts of the transponder project at DEFCON 31, where broadband digital communications and open source electric propulsion will be featured. Find out how to support or join this and other teams at https://openresearch.institute/getting-started

AmbaSat for 70 cm: We’ve redesigned the AmbaSat board to move it from 915 MHz to 70 cm and it will be flown on a sounding rocket this year. With increasing interest in LoRa for both space and terrestrial use, this has proven to be a popular and useful project. The design has been adapted for applications in India and Japan.

Opulent Voice: a digital protocol that seamlessly combines high fidelity voice and data, using modern forward error correction, authentication and authorization, and efficient minimum frequency shift keying modulation. Opulent Voice will be flown on a sounding rocket this year and it is the native digital uplink protocol for Haifuraiya. Completely open with the high quality voice we deserve to hear. Due to the bandwidth requirements of the 16kHz OPUS codec, Opulent Voice can be used on 70cm and above ham bands, or anywhere else where the modest bandwidth requirements can be met.

Remote Labs: We have two remotely accessible workbenches for FPGA development, with Xilinx 7000 and Xilinx Ultrascale+ development boards as the focus. We also have several SDRs and radio utility devices available through virtual machine access. The 7000 series development board has an Analog Devices ADRV9371 radio system attached, and that has enabled a number of open source FPGA products to be published. This is a unique resource that has produced a lot of good work and is constantly being improved and updated. In addition to the development boards, the laboratory has a network accessible spectrum analyzer, an oscilloscope with logic analyzer extension, power supplies, frequency and power counters, and dedicated human resources available to help students, volunteers, or professionals contribute to open source work. Help it be more useful by spreading the word about ORI Remote Labs.

Equipment available: https://github.com/phase4ground/documents/tree/master/Remote_Labs/Test_Equipment
How to get an account: https://github.com/phase4ground/documents/blob/master/Remote_Labs/ORI-New-User-Setup.md
Using FPGA Development Stations: https://github.com/phase4ground/documents/blob/master/Remote_Labs/Working-With-FPGAs.md

Versatune: amateur digital television next generation hardware and software product. It is open source and affordable. We have committed engineering resources to support Versatune and are very excited about how things are going. Some of the Versatune team will be at Hamvention 2023 in Xenia, OH, USA, and it will be represented at DEFCON in August 2023.

HF antennas: We have a novel foldable antenna design for space and terrestrial use. The hardware prototype will be demonstrated at DEFCON. This design manipulates radiation resistance to produce best-of-class results. Think you can’t do 160m without an enormous antenna? Think again.

HF QRP: Coming soon, an exciting HF QRP digital radio board and protocol. The hardware prototypes will be demonstrated at DEFCON. What might happen when we combine the HF digital radio with the novel foldable antenna? We think you’ll be delighted.

Battery Matching Curves: are you available to mentor a college student interested in learning how to match up charge and discharge curves from NiCd cells in order to create battery packs? These packs would then be tested and/or deployed in the field. Our student volunteer has collected the data and is looking to learn how to use Jupyter Notebooks to select the cells to create battery packs.

Logistics

We’re growing and adapting!

We will be changing our GitHub project name from Phase4Ground to Open Research Institute very soon. Phase4Space GitHub project will change to Haifuraiya, which is the program name for our HEO/GEO design. These changes better reflect the content and purpose of the 64 repositories that span everything from important historical archives to open source music to the most modern open source encoders available.

We have a very well-qualified applicant for our open board of directors position. We would like to invite interested community members to consider applying to ORI in order to expand the board beyond this filled position in order to take us from our current five members to seven. Given our continuing growth, a larger leadership team would ensure continued smooth operations. These positions are unpaid, engaging, and can be demanding. The most important skill set is a strong sense of ethics and service.

Fundraising and Grants

We’ve applied for the GitHub Accelerator Program (Remote Labs) and the IEEE Innovation Fund (Polar Codes in Ribbit). If you have a recommendation for ORI in terms of partnerships or collaboration, please let us know at hello@openresearch.institute

Support ORI financially directly through the website https://openresearch.institute. There is a PayPal donation widget at the bottom of almost every page. Donations can be directed to any project, or to general operations. ORI has a very low overhead, with most projects coming in under 5%.

Support our open source propulsion work and get a cool desk toy at https://us.commitchange.com/ca/san-diego/open-research-institute/campaigns/where-will-we-go-next

We’ve raised enough money to cover materials for machining the engine parts. The next step is to raise enough money to pay for the electronics. Please help spread the word!

Thanks to our wonderful community, we have employee matching in place at Microsoft and Qualcomm. If you have an employee matching program at your work, and you think ORI would fit in, please consider nominating us. Our EIN is EIN: 82-3945232

Events

Where can you meet up with ORI people?

QSO Today Ham Expo

We support and attend QSO Today Ham Expo, held online 25-26 March 2023. The theme of this event is “New License, Now What?” and focuses on people new to amateur radio.

Our page for QSO Today Ham Expo content is https://www.openresearch.institute/qso-today-ham-expo-technical-demonstrations/

IMS2023

Join us at the amateur radio social at the International Microwave Symposium (IMS2023) on Tuesday 13 June 2023 in San Diego, CA, USA at 6pm. It will be held in a beautiful outdoor venue with food and drink provided. The easiest way to register for this event is to purchase an exhibition badge and then sign up for the social. https://ims-ieee.org/ is the event website.

DEFCON

We are getting ready for our biggest event of the year. We have proposed an in-person Open Source Showcase to RF Village for DEFCON 31 in Las Vegas, Nevada, USA from 10 – 13 August 2023.

Our page for the event, with all the latest and greatest details, can be found at https://www.openresearch.institute/defcon/

Want to help at DEFCON? Please visit https://openresearch.institute/getting-started and let us know!

IWRC 2023

IEEE wants to bring together all participants to take full advantage of CHIPS Act funding. IEEE will have an Innovative Workforce Resources Conference in Little Rock, AR 13-14 September. There will be a reception at the Clinton Presidential Library, and attendees will enjoy the best BBQ in the country. The National Science Foundation requires that a certain percentage of funding has to be spent in states that don’t get their fair share of research money. The goal of this conference is to pull together small researchers from small business like ORI and do research, with Arkansas as a focus.

We couldn’t agree more. After all, we are putting a lot of time and energy into Remote Labs South, located just outside Little Rock, AR. Bringing innovative open source digital radio work to students, workers, and volunteers that need it the most simply makes sense. If you can attend IWRC 2023 and help represent ORI please get in touch. We will be reaching out to IEEE chapters in Arkansas as well.

Read about the CHIPS and Science Act here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CHIPS_and_Science_Act

Puzzle Solution

43 is the largest number of nuggets that cannot be ordered.

What is the largest number of McNuggets that you can’t buy with packs of 6, 9 and 20? After putting in their blood, sweat, and tears, the mathematicians found that the answer is 43. You cannot buy 43 nuggets with packs of 6, 9 and 20, but you can buy any amount larger than 43.

Please see Mike Beneshan’s excellent blog about this type of problem at https://mikebeneschan.medium.com/the-chicken-mcnugget-theorem-explained-2daca6fbbe1e

The other Non-McNugget numbers are 1,2,3,4,5,7,8,10,11,13,14,16,17,19,22,23,25,28,31,34, and 37.

Trivia: You can get 47 in two ways: 36+19+120 or 06+39+120.

We’ve used the McDonald’s version of the chicken nugget to present and frame this mathematical puzzle. Here’s a link about the history of this menu item: https://www.thrillist.com/news/nation/history-of-chicken-mcnuggets

Robert C. Baker invented the chicken nugget, among many other things. He was a true innovator of what can be fairly called “modern foods”. A brief wikipedia article about him can be found here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_C._Baker

A song written about this remarkable inventor can be enjoyed at this link: https://youtu.be/OEa8wqv4QM0

Do you have an idea for an interdisciplinary puzzle for our next newsletter? We’d love to hear about it. Write ori@openresearch.institute

Until Next Time

Thank you so much for being part of our Inner Circle! You are the motivation for all of this work, provided to the general public for free. We believe it makes the world a better place.

AmbaSat Inspired Sensors Project Kick-Off In December 2020

We are pleased to announce AmbaSat Inspired Sensors as a formal ORI project.

Please visit https://www.openresearch.institute/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Ambasat-Inspired-Custom-Sensors.pdf to read the proposal document.

Unboxing photographs of flight and lab hardware, with UV sensor included, can be seen here: https://www.flickr.com/photos/w5nyv/albums/72157716833127913

First work session expected December 2020 – May 2021 centered at Villanova University. Principal Investigator is Dr. Alan Johnston.